Decent lip liner pencils. they don’t go on the smoothest as i’ve had some crumbling, but they blend as well as a pencil. lasts as long as m a c, but i feel like all pencils last the same amount of time, which is as long as you have up til you eat.

Honestly worth the money the formula is great the pigment is there it’s a non waxy pencil that goes on smooth and lasts the color range is great and you get a good amount for the price you pay would definitely buy again!

This is one of the best lip liners i’ve ever had the different color choices are so good and easy to put on your lips

Has awesome colors to choose from. product is easy to put on goes on well.

Very good, they leave a great finish and the tones are beautiful.